Panther’s Toothsayer: High Point at Charleston Southern

📍 Setting the Stage

High Point hits the road riding both momentum and expectation. The Panthers enter Saturday 3–0 in Big South play, winners of 17 straight conference games, fresh off a historic 104–49 dismantling of Gardner-Webb, the largest margin of victory over a Division I opponent in program history and the biggest Big South blowout the conference has ever seen.

HPU winning comfortably isn’t something new. It’s now the standard.

But this is not a comfortable road trip. It’s more like choppy waters.

Charleston Southern waits inside one of the most unforgiving environments in the league: Buccaneer Fieldhouse, a sub-1,000-seat pressure cooker where the walls are tight, the rims feel closer, and visiting rhythm is often disrupted early.

High Point is 28–24 all-time against CSU and has won four straight in the series, but is just 8–17 all-time in North Charleston.

This is not about talent parity. This is about environment, execution, and discipline.

🏴‍☠️ Opponent Overview: Charleston Southern

Charleston Southern enters the game with confidence, belief, and a style built to stress the Panthers.

They are:

• Physical and aggressive on the glass

• Comfortable playing through chaos

• Willing to live with variance

• Dangerous when perimeter shooting finds rhythm

  
  

CSU is coming off a hard-fought, emotional battle at Winthrop—a game that showed both their upside and volatility. They are not elite defensively, but they manufacture extra possessions through rebounding, and in this building, those possessions feel heavier.

This is a team that believes it can punch above its weight—especially at home, in the second-smallest Division I venue in the nation.

🧱 Team Identity: What Charleston Southern Is

Charleston Southern under Saah Nimley is built on emotion, tempo, and pressure.

They:

• Play fast and fearless, especially early

• Shoot a high volume of threes (they take and make the third-most nationally)

• Crash the offensive glass aggressively

• Force defenses into scramble situations

• Feed off crowd energy and momentum swings

  
  

They are not trying to control games for 40 minutes. They are trying to break rhythm, steal confidence, and turn runs into avalanches.

When the threes fall and rebounds bounce their way, CSU becomes uncomfortable to play against. When those things dry up, the margin appears quickly.

🙌 Where the Game Will Be Won

Statistically, HPU has done a strong job defending the three-point line. Opponents are shooting 31.8% from deep against the Panthers, good for the top third nationally in defensive efficiency. They’ve also been effective at preventing shots altogether, ranking 47th nationally in defensive field-goal attempt rate, indicating a scheme that prioritizes running shooters off the line rather than simply contesting.

Approximately 75% of shots against High Point are classified as contested or highly contested. The Achilles’ heel comes with the remaining quarter of attempts, which tend to be open looks generated after offensive rebounds and kick-outs. HPU ranks 35th-worst nationally in second-chance defense, with many of the open or wide-open threes conceded in these scramble situations.

This is where CSU can hurt High Point and where they can close any talent gap.

🧩 Key Buccaneers to Know

⭐ Brycen Blaine (6’3 Sr G) — The Engine

Team leader, volume shooter, emotional tone-setter. Comfortable pulling from deep and attacking off movement.

HPU Key: Chase him off the line and make him score through bodies, not rhythm.

⭐ Al’ahn Sumler (6’5 Jr G) — The Shot Maker

Confident perimeter scorer who thrives in broken possessions and kick-outs.

HPU Key: Close out under control—no fly-bys, no bailout fouls.

⭐ Jesse Hafemeister (6’7 Sr F) — The Glass Cleaner

Physical forward who does damage on second chances and interior rebounds.

HPU Key: Finish possessions. No second looks.

⭐ Luke Williams (6’6 Jr F) — The Connector

Facilitates offense, moves the ball, and punishes lapses with timely shots.

HPU Key: Don’t let him impact the game without scoring.

Bottom line: CSU’s depth is real enough. Their margin depends on which shooters get comfortable.

📊 Matchup Snapshot

For High Point:

• Secure defensive rebounds—one shot must equal one stop

• Disciplined closeouts on perimeter shooters

• Avoid live-ball turnovers in a tight gym

• Absorb the early emotional surge

• Keep the offense flowing—passes over dribbles

• 
  

For Charleston Southern:

• Win the offensive rebounding battle

• Turn second chances into kick-out threes

• Speed the game up early

• Let the crowd amplify pressure

• Hang around long enough for variance to matter

This game will not be decided by aesthetics.It will be decided by control after the first punch.

🧠 Coaching Context

Saah Nimley has installed belief and urgency at Charleston Southern. His teams play like every possession matters and treat every game like a Game 7.

Flynn Clayman’s High Point group, meanwhile, operates from a place of stability. The Panthers are deeper, more versatile, and more comfortable winning in multiple styles.

They’ve already shown the ability to withstand runs, reset, and reassert control.

The question isn’t whether CSU will bring energy—they will. The question is whether High Point stays composed when:

• Shots don’t immediately fall

• Whistles disrupt flow

• The building gets loud

This is a focus test, not a talent test.

🗝️ Keys for High Point

1️⃣ Finish defensive possessions—CSU is #18 in the nation in total rebounding despite not having elite size, cannot let the Bucs continue possessions after a miss and get open looks off them

2️⃣ Shoot confidently and punish the over-help Nimley teaches

3️⃣ Value the ball—HPU has been elite at forcing turnovers meanwhile CSU is near dead last (#358) in the same statistic

4️⃣ Stay connected defensively through scrambles

5️⃣ Respond calmly when the inevitable run comes

If High Point stays disciplined, this becomes a talent problem Charleston Southern will struggle to solve.

🧠 Context That Matters

• HPU has won 17 straight Big South games

• Panthers are allowing opponents just 31.8% from three

  • Open threes typically come via scramble or offensive rebound situations

• CSU’s building historically compresses margins early

• Cam Fletcher’s status remains a storyline…his presence raises the ceiling, but HPU has proven it can thrive regardless. I think the message is pretty clear, buy in or be out. 

🔮 Toothsayer’s Take

This is the kind of game where those who don’t watch closely, or don’t know the history, might assume it will be one-sided. Vegas will likely set a large line based on High Point’s current form and three consecutive double-digit dismantlings of Big South opponents.

I would be hesitant.

This is a true road test against a team that can shoot at an upper-echelon level.

CSU is notably more efficient in the cozy confines of the Buc Dome, shooting roughly 4% better on higher volume at home than away. Conversely, visiting teams often struggle to shoot at their normal clip, especially early, as it takes time to adjust to the depth and sightlines of such a small venue.

Analytics consistently show that teams accustomed to arena-style settings struggle with depth perception at CSU for the first 15–20 minutes. For a High Point team that leans into high-volume shooting, that could mean a slower start in North Charleston.

Charleston Southern will:

• Shoot without fear

• Crash the glass

• Believe the building can carry them

But belief only lasts if possessions are extended.

High Point is deeper. High Point is cleaner. High Point is more complete.

CSU will look to extend possessions on the glass. HPU will look to steal more possessions by forcing turnovers. If the Panthers secure rebounds and prevent CSU’s shooters from igniting early confidence, their overall talent wins out.

But it should be close

Prediction: High Point 84, Charleston Southern 78